Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a commission. This comes at no additional cost to you. For more details, please visit my Affiliate Disclosure page.
See those delicate, flaky layers beneath the pumpkin filling?
That’s what a good flaky pie crust should deliver: tender enough to cut easily with a fork, yet sturdy enough to support a rich, moist filling without losing its crisp texture.
Making a flaky, tender pie crust takes more than a good recipe. This Kitchen Foundations guide walks through the process I use today, from mixing the dough to blind baking and troubleshooting common problems.
Jump to a section:
- How I Finally Learned to Make Flaky Pie Crust
- Why Choose a Combination Pie Crust?
- Maybe Grandma Had It Right All Along
- What Makes a Great Pie Crust?
- Ingredients for this Combination Pie Crust
- Equipment
- How to Make a Combination Pie Dough
- Prepare Your Pie Crust
- Rolling Out the Dough
- Fit the Dough into the Pie Plate
- Unbaked (Raw) Pie Crust
- Par-Baked Pie Crust
- Blind-Baked Pie Crust
- Double-Crust Pie
- Troubleshooting Common Pie Crust Problems
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Jump to the Recipe Card
How I Finally Learned to Make Flaky Pie Crust
I’ve been cooking for nearly sixty years, but for most of that time, I avoided making traditional pie crust. Not because I didn’t enjoy pie. Quite the opposite. I just couldn’t seem to make a crust that turned out the way I wanted.
Over the years, I tried one recipe after another, with mixed results. Some crusts were tough, others shrank during baking, and decorative edges kept disappearing into the pie plate. Sometimes the crust shattered when I cut into it. Other times, it simply wasn’t particularly enjoyable to eat.
Eventually, I stopped fighting it and found workarounds. I chose graham cracker crusts for cream pies, while press-in flour-and-butter crusts worked well enough for other desserts. They were perfectly acceptable alternatives, but avoiding traditional pie crust also meant passing up recipes I would have enjoyed making otherwise.
For years, I assumed pie crust was simply one of those things I couldn’t quite get right. But when I finally decided to tackle it seriously, I discovered that knowing the basic techniques and getting the results I wanted were two very different things.
I understood the importance of keeping the ingredients cold, handling the dough gently, and allowing it to rest. I worked with an all-butter crust, adjusting my technique and paying close attention to how the dough behaved. The results improved, but something was still missing. I wanted a crust that was flaky without being fragile, tender enough to cut easily with a fork, and sturdy enough to support a moist filling without becoming soggy.
The turning point came when I stopped trying to make butter do everything and began working with a combination of butter and vegetable shortening. The shortening brought tenderness, while the butter provided the flavor and flaky layers I wanted. Just as importantly, the way I incorporated those two fats into the flour made a difference.
There wasn’t a secret ingredient or a single technique that suddenly solved everything. It was a matter of understanding what I wanted from the finished crust, choosing ingredients that could deliver those qualities, and bringing them together with the right technique.
That’s the approach behind this combination pie crust. It’s the recipe and method I use today because it produces the kind of crust I enjoy making and serving. Whether you’re baking your first pie or your hundredth, I hope what I’ve learned helps you avoid some of my frustration and make a pie crust you’ll be proud to serve.
Why Choose a Combination Pie Crust?
A combination pie crust brings together the best qualities of butter and vegetable shortening, creating a crust that’s flavorful, flaky, tender, and easier to work with.
Butter provides the rich flavor that complements everything from sweet desserts to savory dishes like quiche. It also helps the crust bake to a beautiful golden brown. As butter melts in the oven, it releases steam that helps create the delicate, flaky layers that make a good pie crust so enjoyable.
Vegetable shortening brings something different to the dough. It helps create a tender crust that’s easier to handle and less prone to shrinking during baking. Because shortening has a higher melting point than butter, it also gives us a little more flexibility when rolling and shaping the dough.
By combining the two, we get the flavor and flakiness of butter with the tenderness and forgiving nature of shortening. The result is a crust that’s not only delicious but sturdy enough to hold together from the first slice to the last bite.

Maybe Grandma Had It Right All Along
There’s something mildly humbling about spending decades struggling to make a good pie crust, only to discover that generations of home bakers had already figured out much of what I was trying to accomplish.
Long before food processors, refrigerated pie dough, and the modern fascination with all-butter pastry, home cooks were making wonderfully tender, flaky pie crusts with simple ingredients and ordinary kitchen tools. Many relied on lard, sometimes combining it with butter to get the qualities they wanted from both fats.
And they weren’t doing it because they didn’t know any better.
Lard had some very practical advantages. It produced tender pastry, worked easily into flour, and helped create crusts that held together without becoming tough. Butter, meanwhile, contributed the rich flavor that makes a good pie crust so satisfying.
As vegetable shortening became widely available in the early twentieth century, it offered home bakers a convenient alternative to lard. Products like Crisco provided a neutral-flavored, consistent fat that could deliver much of the same tenderness without the need to render or source good-quality lard.
Combining fats wasn’t a shortcut or a compromise. It was a practical way to use what each ingredient did best. Whether the combination was butter and lard or butter and vegetable shortening, the objective was much the same: a tender, flaky crust with good flavor.
Somewhere along the way, all-butter pie crust became something of a gold standard. And there’s nothing wrong with an excellent all-butter crust. But after working through my own frustrations, I began to wonder whether I’d been making things unnecessarily difficult by insisting that butter do everything.
As it turns out, the solution wasn’t particularly revolutionary. I simply returned to an approach that generations of bakers would have recognized: use one fat for tenderness and another for flavor and flakiness.
I suppose my Grandma might have smiled at how long it took me to figure that out.
What Makes a Great Pie Crust?
A great pie crust should do more than look flaky. It should hold together when you slice the pie, stay crisp beneath the filling, and be tender enough that each bite practically melts away.
For me, the best pie crust supports the filling without becoming the center of attention. It adds texture and flavor to every bite, but the pie itself remains the star.
Those qualities don’t happen by accident. They come from understanding how the dough behaves and giving each step the attention it deserves. The rest of this guide will show you the techniques that make that possible.
Ingredients for this Combination Pie Crust
This pie crust has only five basic ingredients plus optional sugar, but each one plays an important role. As you work through the recipe, I’ll explain not only what each ingredient does, but why using it correctly makes a better crust.
- Gold Medal All-Purpose Flour: All-purpose flour provides the structure that holds the crust together. It has enough protein to create a sturdy pastry without making it tough, provided the dough isn’t overworked. I use Gold Medal because it gives me consistent results. Weighing the flour is especially important here; too much flour can produce a dry, crumbly dough that’s difficult to roll
- Kosher Salt: Salt does more than add a salty taste. It enhances the flavor of the butter and flour, giving the finished pastry a richer, more balanced flavor. Without it, even a beautifully flaky crust can taste surprisingly flat.
- Granulated Sugar (Optional — Recommended for Sweet Pies): A tablespoon of sugar adds just a hint of sweetness and encourages browning during baking. It won’t make the crust noticeably sweet, but it complements fruit and custard fillings beautifully. For savory pies, simply leave it out.
- Crisco Vegetable Shortening: Shortening is one of the secrets to this crust’s tenderness. Unlike butter, shortening contains no water, so it doesn’t produce steam during baking. Working it thoroughly into the flour coats some of the flour particles with fat, limiting gluten development and helping create a tender pastry that’s easy to cut with a fork. I use Crisco for its consistent texture and reliable results.
- Land O’Lakes Unsalted Butter — VERY Cold: Butter provides the rich flavor and beautiful browning that shortening alone can’t deliver. Keeping it very cold is essential. As the crust bakes, the water in the butter turns to steam, helping separate the dough into delicate, flaky layers. I add the butter after incorporating the shortening, leaving small pieces distributed throughout the dough rather than blending everything into a uniform mixture.
- Ice Water: Water brings the flour and fats together into a dough that can be rolled and shaped. The key is using only enough to make the dough hold together. Too much water encourages gluten development, which can make the crust tough. Ice water also helps keep the butter cold while the dough comes together. Add it gradually and let the dough’s texture, rather than an exact measurement, tell you when to stop.
Equipment
For years, I assumed a food processor was the key to making a great pie crust. Many of the recipes I found called for one, so I figured it was simply part of the process.
Then one day I realized my mother never owned a food processor. Neither did my grandmother, nor the generations before her. They were making pie crusts long before food processors existed, so maybe that wasn’t the secret after all.
After a lot of testing, I discovered I was right. Today I make this crust with nothing more than a fork and a pastry cutter, a mixing bowl, and a silicone spatula. Not only is cleanup easier, but I also find I have better control over the dough’s texture.
You don’t need specialized pastry equipment to make an excellent pie crust. A few basic kitchen tools are all it takes.
- Large mixing bowl – Gives you room to incorporate the shortening, cut in the butter, and gently bring the dough together without making a mess.
- A fork – Works the vegetable shortening into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse, grainy sand, creating a tender foundation for the crust.
- Pastry cutter – Cuts cold butter into the flour while leaving small pieces intact, helping create a flaky crust.
- Silicone spatula – Makes it easy to fold the dough together without overworking it and helps scrape every bit from the bowl.
- Rolling pin – Rolls the dough evenly to the proper thickness.
- 9-inch glass pie plate – Glass makes it easier to monitor browning on the bottom of the crust.
- Parchment paper and pie weights – Used for blind baking to keep the crust from puffing or sliding before it sets.
- Kitchen scale (recommended) – The easiest way to measure flour accurately and produce consistent results.
- Plastic wrap – Keeps the dough from drying out while it rests in the refrigerator.
How to Make Combination Pie Dough
Prepare Your Ingredients
- Before you begin, weigh the flour, measure the salt and vegetable shortening, and cut the cold butter into ½-inch cubes; return it to the refrigerator while you prepare the remaining ingredients. Fill a measuring cup with ice water, and have your fork, pastry cutter, silicone spatula, and plastic wrap within easy reach.

- Taking a few minutes to prep everything beforehand makes the process smoother and helps keep the butter cold while you work. Cold butter is key to a flaky pie crust because those small pieces create flaky layers as the crust bakes.
- If you’re unfamiliar with mise en place, I explain why it’s one of the most valuable habits a home cook can develop in my article “Mastering Mise en Place: The Secret to Stress-Free Cooking.”
Why Measure Flour by Weight?
Flour is surprisingly difficult to measure consistently with a measuring cup. Scooping directly from the bag compresses the flour, while lightly spooning it into the cup leaves it much looser. Both methods may look like 1¼ cups, but they can differ enough to affect the finished pie crust.
That difference matters. Too much flour can make the dough dry, crumbly, and difficult to bring together. Too little can leave it sticky and hard to handle. Measuring 155 grams with a kitchen scale removes that uncertainty and gives you the same starting point every time.

I’ve included the cup measurement for cooks who don’t use a kitchen scale. If you’re measuring by volume, lightly spoon the flour into the measuring cup and level it off without packing it down. For the most consistent results, however, use the weight as the definitive measurement.
Combine the Dry Ingredients
- Add the flour, kosher salt, and granulated sugar (if using) to a large mixing bowl and whisk them together until evenly combined. Whisking distributes the salt throughout the flour so every bite of the finished crust is properly seasoned.

Incorporate the Vegetable Shortening
- Add the vegetable shortening to the flour mixture. Using a fork, work the shortening into the flour, pressing and stirring until evenly distributed and resembling coarse, grainy sand.


- Continue working the mixture until no large pieces of shortening remain. The flour should appear slightly clumpy but remain loose and granular. This is the texture you’re looking for before adding the butter.

Cut in the Butter
- Scatter the cold butter cubes over the flour and shortening mixture. Using a pastry cutter, work the butter into the mixture until it resembles coarse crumbs and larger, irregular clumps begin to form.


- Stop cutting when those larger clumps appear. The mixture should still be predominantly crumbly, with some larger pieces scattered throughout. This is the texture you’re looking for before adding the ice water.

- Unlike the shortening, which we worked thoroughly into the flour, we want to preserve small pieces of butter throughout the mixture. As the crust bakes, the butter melts and releases steam, helping create the flaky layers that make homemade pie crust so special.
Add the Ice Water
- Sprinkle 2 tablespoons of ice water over the flour mixture. Using a silicone spatula, gently fold the mixture together. Continue adding ice water, about a teaspoon at a time, until the dough holds together when squeezed in your hand. You may need approximately 3 to 4 tablespoons of water in total.

- The goal isn’t a wet or sticky dough. You’re adding just enough water to bring the ingredients together. The mixture may still look somewhat crumbly, but it should hold together when pressed. Adding more water than necessary encourages gluten development, which can make the finished crust tougher.
Why Ice Water?
Butter is what creates a flaky pie crust. As the pie bakes, small pieces of cold butter melt and release steam, separating the dough into delicate layers.
If the butter softens while you’re mixing the dough, it blends into the flour instead of staying in distinct pieces. The result is a denser, less flaky crust.
Ice water helps prevent that. It provides the moisture needed to bring the dough together while helping the butter stay cold until the crust reaches the oven.
The goal isn’t to make the dough cold for its own sake. The goal is to preserve small pieces of butter throughout the dough so they can do their job during baking.
Bring the Dough Together
- Once the dough begins to come together, gently gather it into a rough ball. Don’t knead it like bread dough. A little shaggy texture is perfectly normal and will disappear as the dough rests.

Form a Disk
- Flatten the dough into a disk about 1 inch thick, then wrap it tightly in plastic wrap.


- A disk chills more evenly than a ball and is much easier to roll into a circle later.
Refrigerate the Dough
- Refrigerate it for at least 1 hour.
- This resting time does more than simply chill the butter. It allows the flour to fully hydrate and gives the gluten time to relax. Skipping this step often results in dough that shrinks when you roll or bake it.
Prepare Your Pie Crust
Once your dough has chilled, how you prepare it depends on the pie you’re making. Some pies are filled and baked in a raw crust, while others need a partially or fully baked crust before adding the filling. Double-crust pies add a second dough layer for the top.
How you prepare the crust depends on the pie you’re making:
- Unbaked (Raw) Pie Crust: The raw crust and filling bake together. This is typical for pies with fillings that need a long time in the oven, such as pumpkin, pecan, and many fruit pies.
- Par-Baked Pie Crust: Bake the crust first, then add the filling and finish baking. This is useful when the filling needs less baking time than the crust or when you want extra protection against a soggy bottom crust.
- Blind-Baked Pie Crust: Bake the crust completely before adding the filling. Use this for fillings that require little or no additional baking, such as cream, pudding, or other chilled pies.
- Double-Crust Pie: A bottom crust and a top crust surround the filling and bake together. This is most commonly used for fruit pies and other fillings that benefit from being enclosed while they bake.
Rolling Out the Dough
- Remove the chilled dough from the refrigerator and place it on a lightly floured work surface. If the dough feels very firm, let it rest at room temperature for 5 to 10 minutes. It should remain cold but become pliable enough to roll without cracking around the edges.
- Lightly flour the top of the dough and your rolling pin. Place the rolling pin in the center of the dough and roll outward, rotating the dough a quarter turn every few passes to keep it round. Rotating the dough also makes it easier to tell when it begins sticking to the work surface.

- As you rotate the dough, you’ll likely find it needs a light dusting of flour from time to time. That’s perfectly normal. Use only enough flour to keep the dough moving freely. Too much flour can dry the dough’s surface, while too little can make it stick and tear.
- One mistake many home bakers make is rolling the dough as thin as possible. For this recipe, that’s not the goal.
- During testing, I found that leaving the dough slightly thicker produced a crust with a better bite and enough structure to hold its shape during baking. If the dough becomes too thin, it can become fragile and is more likely to shrink or lose its decorative edge.
- As a general guide, I roll this dough to about 3/16 to 1/4 inch thick. You don’t need to obsess over that measurement, and you certainly don’t need a ruler or calipers next to your rolling pin. Just avoid rolling the dough paper-thin.
- Roll the dough into a circle about 12 inches in diameter for a standard 9-inch pie plate. It doesn’t need to be perfectly round. You’re simply looking for enough dough to cover the bottom and sides of the plate with some extra around the edge. That extra dough gives us what we need to fit the crust into the plate without stretching it, and we can finish the edge later.
Fit the Dough Into the Pie Plate
- Transferring the dough is easier if you loosely roll it around your rolling pin, then unroll it over the pie plate. You can also gently fold the dough into quarters, transfer it to the plate, and unfold it. Either method works; the goal is simply to move the dough without pulling or tearing it.
- Center the dough over the pie plate so you have roughly the same amount of overhang all the way around. Don’t worry if it isn’t perfectly even. As long as you have enough dough around the entire edge, you’re in good shape.
- Gently lift the dough at the edge and allow it to settle into the bottom and corners of the pie plate. Work your way around the plate, lifting and settling the dough a little at a time until it rests naturally against the bottom and sides.
- Don’t stretch or pull the dough to make it fit. Stretched dough wants to return to its original shape as it bakes, which is one reason pie crusts shrink down the sides of the plate. If the dough doesn’t reach a corner, lift it from the edge and give it enough slack to settle into place instead.
- Once the dough fits into the plate, leave the excess hanging over the edge for now. How you trim, fold, seal, or crimp that overhang depends on whether you’re making a single-crust or double-crust pie, so we’ll handle the edge as we prepare the crust for your particular pie.

Unbaked (Raw) Pie Crust
- Use an unbaked, or raw, crust when the filling and crust will spend enough time in the oven to bake together. Pumpkin, pecan, and many fruit pies are commonly baked this way. If your pie recipe specifically calls for a par-baked crust, follow those instructions instead.
- Trim the overhang so about 1/2 to 3/4 inch of dough extends beyond the edge of the pie plate. Fold the excess dough underneath itself to create a thicker, sturdy rim. Work gently, and avoid pulling or stretching the dough.
- Crimp or flute the edge however you like. I usually use one knuckle and the thumb and forefinger of the other to make a simple fluted edge. It doesn’t have to be perfectly uniform; an even, well-supported rim that holds its shape during baking is more important than perfect decoration.

- Refrigerate the prepared crust for at least 30 minutes before filling it. Rolling and shaping warm the dough and work it. Chilling firms the butter again and lets the dough relax, helping the crust hold its shape once it reaches the oven.
- Once the crust is thoroughly chilled, add the filling and bake according to the recipe for the pie you’re making. Filling temperatures, oven temperatures, and baking times vary considerably, so the individual pie recipe should determine what happens from here.
Par-Baked Pie Crust
- A par-baked crust is partially baked before you add the filling, giving the bottom crust a head start before it returns to the oven with the filling. This method is commonly used for quiche and some savory tarts, where the filling may finish cooking before a raw bottom crust has time to bake thoroughly. You can also use it whenever a pie recipe calls for the crust to get a head start before adding the filling.
- Trim the overhang so about 1/2 to 3/4 inch of dough extends beyond the pie plate, then fold the excess underneath itself to create a sturdy rim. Crimp or flute the edge as desired, working gently so you don’t stretch the dough.
- Refrigerate the prepared pie shell for at least 1 hour. The dough should be thoroughly cold and firm.
A Word About Docking
Docking is simply making small holes in pie dough to allow trapped steam to escape during baking. It helps prevent the bottom crust from puffing up or developing large bubbles.
When using parchment paper and pie weights, there’s generally no need to dock the crust before baking. The weights help keep the dough flat while it begins to set.
After removing the parchment and weights, inspect the bottom of the crust. If you notice any areas beginning to puff or form bubbles, gently prick those spots with a fork to release the trapped steam. There’s no need to puncture the entire bottom or sides.
Only dock when necessary. Leaving the crust intact is particularly helpful when preparing pies with wet fillings, such as pumpkin or custard, where you want to keep the bottom crust as well sealed as possible.
- Preheat the oven to 425°F. Line the chilled crust with parchment paper, leaving enough excess to make it easy to lift out later. Fill the crust with pie weights, dried beans, or uncooked rice, making sure the weights cover the bottom and extend well up the sides. Supporting the sides helps prevent the crust from slumping as the butter melts and the dough sets. Place a silicone pie crust shield over the rim to protect the decorative edges from excessive browning during par-baking. If you don’t have a silicone shield, use a loosely fitted ring of aluminum foil instead.

- Bake the weighted crust for about 20 minutes, until the edge begins to take on a little color and the dough underneath the parchment starts to set.
- Carefully lift out the parchment and pie weights. If you notice any areas of the bottom beginning to puff, gently prick those spots with a fork to release the trapped steam. If the bottom is lying flat, leave it alone.
- After removing the parchment and pie weights, lightly beat 1 egg with 1 teaspoon of water until well combined. Using a pastry brush, apply a thin, even coating to the bottom and inside walls of the crust. Return the crust to the 425°F oven for about 2–4 minutes, until the egg wash sets and the surface is dry. This creates a protective seal that helps keep the crust crisp when you add a moist filling.
- At this point, the crust is only partially baked. Add the filling and continue baking according to your recipe. The crust will finish baking along with the filling.

Blind-Baked Pie Crust
- A blind-baked crust is fully baked before you add the filling. Choose this when the filling won’t bake long enough to finish the crust—or won’t bake at all. Cream pies, pudding pies, and other chilled or no-bake fillings typically require a fully baked crust.
- Trim the overhang so about 1/2 to 3/4 inch of dough extends beyond the pie plate, then fold the excess underneath itself to create a sturdy rim. Crimp or flute the edge as desired, working gently so you don’t stretch the dough.
- Refrigerate the prepared pie shell for at least 1 hour. The dough should be thoroughly cold and firm.
- Preheat the oven to 425°F. Line the chilled crust with parchment paper, leaving enough excess to make it easy to lift out later. Fill the crust with pie weights, dried beans, or uncooked rice, making sure the weights cover the bottom and extend well up the sides. Supporting the sides helps prevent the crust from slumping as the butter melts and the dough sets. Place a silicone pie crust shield over the rim to protect the decorative edges from excessive browning during baking. If you don’t have a silicone shield, use a loosely fitted ring of aluminum foil instead.

- Bake the weighted crust for about 20 minutes, until the edges are beginning to turn lightly golden and the dough has set enough to hold its shape.
- Carefully lift out the parchment and pie weights. If you notice any areas of the bottom beginning to puff, gently prick those spots with a fork to release the trapped steam. If the bottom is lying flat, leave it alone.
- After removing the parchment and pie weights, return the uncovered crust to the 425°F oven for another 5–10 minutes, until the bottom is dry and the crust is evenly golden brown.
- Meanwhile, lightly beat 1 egg with 1 teaspoon of water until well combined. Once the crust is fully baked, use a pastry brush to apply a thin, even coating of egg wash to the bottom and inside walls. Return the crust to the oven for another 2–4 minutes, just until the egg wash has set and the surface is dry. This creates a protective seal that helps prevent moisture from the filling from softening the crisp pastry.
- Watch the rim of the crust during these final minutes; if it begins browning faster than the bottom, loosely cover the edge with foil.
- Let the crust cool completely before adding a chilled or no-bake filling. At this point, the crust is fully baked, so the filling recipe determines everything that happens next.

Double-Crust Pie
- A double-crust pie uses one crust on the bottom and a second crust over the filling. Fruit pies are the most common example. You’ll need two separate batches of this recipe—one disk for the bottom crust and one for the top.
- Roll the first disk and fit it into the pie plate using the techniques described above. Leave the excess dough hanging over the edge rather than trimming, folding, or crimping it. Refrigerate the fitted bottom crust while you prepare the filling and roll the second disk.
- Add the filling to the chilled bottom crust, following the recipe for the pie you’re making. Roll the second disk to about the same thickness as the bottom crust and large enough to completely cover the pie, with some dough extending beyond the edge.
- Transfer the top crust over the filling and center it on the pie. Trim the top and bottom crusts together, leaving about 1/2 to 3/4 inch of dough beyond the edge of the pie plate.

- Press the edges of the top and bottom crusts together to seal them, then fold the joined edge underneath itself to create a sturdy rim. Crimp or flute the rim as you would a single crust. The goal is both decorative and functional—a good seal helps keep the filling inside the pie as it bakes.
- Cut several slits in the top crust with a sharp paring knife to allow steam to escape during baking. Without vents, pressure from the hot filling can build beneath the crust and force its way out around the edges.
- Refrigerate the assembled pie for about 30 minutes before baking. This firms the butter again after rolling and shaping and gives the dough another opportunity to relax.
- If the pie recipe calls for an egg wash, milk, cream, coarse sugar, or another finish, apply it just before the pie goes into the oven. Bake according to the filling recipe, since the appropriate temperature and baking time depend on the pie you’re making.

Troubleshooting Common Pie Crust Problems
Even when you follow a recipe carefully, pie dough can sometimes behave differently than expected. The important thing is understanding what the dough or crust is telling you.
Most pie crust problems actually begin well before you see the result. For example, a crust that shrinks in the oven may trace back to how you fitted the dough into the pie plate. Use the common problems below to help identify what likely happened, then follow the links back to the technique that can help prevent it next time.
Why Is My Pie Dough Cracking When I Roll It Out?
If chilled pie dough cracks around the edges as you begin rolling, it may simply be too cold and firm. Let it rest at room temperature for 5–10 minutes, then try again. The dough should remain cool but become flexible enough to roll without breaking apart.
If the dough still cracks or crumbles after softening slightly, it may not have enough water. When making your next crust, pay particular attention to the dough’s texture as you add the ice water. Add only enough for the dough to hold together when gently pressed.
Why Did My Pie Crust Shrink?
Pie crust can shrink when you stretch the dough to fit the pie plate. The dough may seem to cooperate while you assemble the pie, but it can contract back toward its original shape as it bakes.
Instead of stretching the dough, gently lift the edges and let it settle naturally against the bottom and sides of the plate. See Fit the Dough Into the Pie Plate for the technique.
Adequate chilling also gives the dough time to relax before it enters the oven. Follow the chilling instructions for your crust type before filling or baking.
Why is My Pie Crust Tough?
A tough crust often results from developing too much gluten. This can happen when you work the dough more than necessary or add more water than the flour needs.
When adding the ice water, stop as soon as the dough holds together when gently pressed. Then, bring the dough together, handling it only enough to form a cohesive dough. Pie dough doesn’t need kneading or working until it’s smooth.
Why Isn’t My Pie Crust Flaky?
Flaky layers start with pieces of cold butter left in the dough. As the crust bakes, the butter melts, and its water turns to steam, helping separate the dough into layers.
If the butter gets too warm or you work it completely into the flour, you lose some of that layering potential. When cutting in the butter, stop once larger, irregular clumps begin forming among the coarse crumbs. The mixture should still be predominantly crumbly, with small pieces of butter remaining throughout. Keeping the ingredients and dough cold helps preserve those pieces until the crust reaches the oven.
Why Did My Pie Crust Puff or Bubble While Baking?
Pie crust can puff or bubble when steam becomes trapped beneath the dough during baking. Lining the crust with parchment paper and filling it with pie weights helps keep the dough flat as it sets, so you generally don’t need to dock the crust beforehand.
After removing the parchment and weights, inspect the bottom of the crust. If any areas begin to puff or form bubbles, gently prick those spots with a fork to release the trapped steam, then continue baking as directed. If the crust remains flat, leave it alone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Make Pie Dough Ahead of Time?
Yes. After forming the dough into a disk, wrap it tightly and refrigerate it for up to 3 days. When you’re ready to use it, let the dough sit at room temperature for 5–10 minutes if it’s too firm to roll without cracking.
For longer storage, wrap the disk well and freeze it for up to 3 months. Thaw it overnight in the refrigerator before rolling.
Can I Freeze an Unbaked Pie Crust?
Yes. You can roll the dough, fit it into the pie plate, finish the edge, and freeze the prepared crust until you’re ready to use it. Once the crust is frozen solid, wrap it well to protect it from drying out and absorbing freezer odors.
If you’re using a glass pie plate, avoid moving it directly from the freezer into a hot oven. The sudden temperature change can cause thermal shock and potentially break the glass. Let the pie plate warm gradually before baking, following your bakeware manufacturer’s recommendations.
Can I Use This Pie Crust for Savory Pies?
Absolutely. This combination pie crust works well for both sweet and savory pies. For a savory crust, simply omit the tablespoon of sugar.
Can I Double the Recipe for a Double-Crust Pie?
A double-crust pie needs twice as much dough, but I recommend making two separate batches rather than doubling everything in one bowl.
I developed and tested this recipe as a one-crust batch. That amount makes it easier to cut the butter evenly into the flour, add only as much water as the dough needs, and bring everything together without overworking it.
Making two batches also gives you two manageable disks—one for the bottom crust and one for the top. It takes a few extra minutes, but it keeps the process consistent with the method the recipe was developed around and makes the results more reproducible.
If you found this post helpful…
There’s more.
Recipes you won’t always find on the site, a few new techniques, and a better sense of what matters when you’re cooking.
Flaky Pie Crust Recipe (Butter and Shortening)
This combination pie crust is flaky, tender, and full of buttery flavor. Made by hand with a pastry cutter and a few simple ingredients, the dough is easy to work with and makes one 9-inch pie crust for your favorite sweet or savory pies.
- Prep Time: 15 minutes
- Chilling Time: 60 minutes
- Total Time: 1 hour 15 minutes
- Yield: 1 pie crust 1x
- Category: Pastry
- Cuisine: American
Ingredients
- 155 g all-purpose flour (about 1 1/4 cups)
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1 tablespoon granulated sugar (optional for sweet pies)
- 45 g Crisco, chilled (about 4 tablespoons)
- 68 g unsalted butter (about 5 tablespoons), cold, cut into 1/2″ cubes
- 3–4 tablespoons ice water, as needed
Instructions
Mixing the Dough
- Combine the dry ingredients. In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the flour and kosher salt. If making a sweet pie, add the optional sugar at this stage.
- Incorporate the shortening. Add the chilled vegetable shortening to the flour mixture. Using a fork, press and work the shortening into the flour until evenly distributed and the mixture resembles fine, grainy sand.
- Cut in the butter. Add the cold, cubed butter. Using a pastry cutter, work the butter into the flour mixture until coarse crumbs form. Continue cutting until the mixture begins to gather into larger, irregular clumps. Small, flattened pieces of butter should still be visible throughout the flour.
- Add the ice water. Begin with 2 tablespoons of ice water, gently folding it into the mixture with a silicone spatula. Continue adding water, a little at a time, folding gently after each addition, just until the dough begins to hold together. The dough should form soft, irregular clumps and hold its shape when pressed together without feeling wet or sticky. Typically, 3–4 tablespoons of water will be sufficient.
- Form the dough. Gently gather the dough together and press it into a cohesive mound. Transfer it to a sheet of plastic wrap and shape it into a flattened disc approximately 1 inch thick. Avoid kneading or overworking the dough; a few small cracks on the surface are perfectly normal.
- Wrap and chill. Wrap the dough tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 1 hour before rolling. The chilled dough is now ready for a single 9-inch pie crust. Follow the instructions in the article above (Prepare Your Pie Crust) for instructions on rolling and preparing the dough for the type of pie you’re making.


